Skip to main content

"Did Evaluation Kill My Singing Career?"

My wife and I spent last Friday night listening to a motivational speaker, Eddie Slowikowski.  If you are a runner, then that name might be familiar to you - Eddie is one of the few individuals in the world that has run a sub four-minute mile.

Fleet footwork aside - his primary message was that it takes belief, a positive attitude, and hard work to achieve success and overcome life's inevitable setbacks.  He also stressed that we as parents and educators need to help children assess their unique abilities and help them turn their passion into a life's ambition and adventure.

Eddie's presentation was very energetic and engaging - with dancing, emotional stories, and motivating perspectives.  At one point, Eddie asked the audience to stand up when voting yes to a particular personal talent assessment:

  • How many of you can sing?  (about 1/3 of the audience stood up - my wife included)
  • How many of you can draw?  (once again, about 1/3 of the adults stood)
  • How many of you can dance?  (I stood with, once again, about 1/3 of the audience)
His next point sent my mind spinning into memories, as well as, instructional thought.
Eddie said, "Did anyone notice that I did not ask if you did any of these things well?" 
"Everyone can sing, draw, and dance to a certain extent."  He explained that when he asks these same questions to a group of young children, they all stand with excitement, eagerness, and anticipation that they will get to demonstrate their "rad" skills.

Eddie went on to explain what I already suspected, that once we start to get evaluated, our vision, our belief, and our self-concepts change.  We develop a more rational mind that tries to protect our egos from disappointment and embarrassment.

I enjoy music, and I would love to be able to sing.  But at some point, when I was much younger, I was told that I could not sing well, and I shifted my pursuits to sports and other "boyish" things.  Conversely, it wasn't until the past few years (I am 48) that I discovered that I have a talent, and a passion for dancing.  Fortunately, my wife suports my passion.  We have taken several ballroom dancing classes, and we go country line-dancing almost every weekend - it is amazing how, after hours of practice - that we can anticipate, and "feel" an upcoming movement.  Natalie doesn't "believe" that she is a good dancer, but she is a fast learner and she loves music.  She does very well on the floor until she thinks that she is being watched, or judged.  Maybe someone doubted her dancing ability when she was young.  Most significantly, Natalie is an outstanding and passionate 2nd grade teacher.  It is because of these combinations of our passions and skills that I can picture us teaching dance lessons sometime in our future.

I remember my parents dancing in our family room to their old collection of 45s.  I remember the music being loud - they looked good, and they were having a lot of fun.  They tried to get my me and my brother to join in - but maybe we were too embarrassed, or maybe we felt silly.  I guess I just finally got to an age where I no longer care about embarrassment, or about being judged.  Maybe it took me a few decades to learn that life is best lived when we pursue and enjoy those activities that we feel passionate about.  Then miraculously, the hard work doesn't feel like work at all!

These concepts can be applied to grading policies in our classrooms.  We need to keep in mind that kids  have unlimited potentials - they can do anything, more importantly - they think they can do anything!  We cannot let an evaluation system smother a child's passion.  After all, if you look closely at a school report card, I will bet you a quarter that somewhere on that form are the words, "PROGRESS REPORT".

So, in the true spirit of a progress report, each student would have an IEP (individualized education plan).  Each student would be allowed to establish a baseline of aptitudes, abilities, and interests.  Each student would then be allowed to frequently self-evaluate their progress towards challenging standards.  Parents and teachers would observe the children, learning about them while recording and sharing areas of particular skill, interest, and passion.  Am I saying that we need to get away from a letter grade evaluation system?  Yes, I am!

What else am I saying?  The same thing that Eddie Slowikowski was saying.  We can accomplish great and rewarding things when we identify our passion and then believe and commit to endeavors, and efforts that foster and support those passions.

My singing career was derailed early on - probably for the best.  However, my teaching / coaching career has been very rewarding and satisfying.  There is nothing better than helping students form, and then work towards, goals that they are passionate about.  My next career, who knows?  It may be as a writer, or a dance instructor.  Either way, much like teaching, it will be an interesting and fun adventure.

Thanks for sharing your message and your passion Eddie - we heard you!


Popular posts from this blog

What Teachers Can Learn From Effective Coaches

In my educational world teaching and coaching involve the same processes. The people that impacted my own learning most significantly were coaches. Could it be that great coaches were ahead of their time with respects to instructional best practices? Let's take a look at ten coaching practices that thankfully have found their way into the classroom. Standards-based Grading - coaches aren't concerned with arbitrary measures of success such as letter grades. Great coaches identify a requisite set of skills that are necessary for advancement and success. Promotion and achievement are based upon clearly identified levels of skill mastery.  Authentic assessment - coaches are looking for their athletes to demonstrate their skill mastery under game-like situations. The best coaches incorporate game simulations and competitive, game-like drills into their practices. Winning coaches will use the contests as assess

Board Games in the School Library: 3 Reasons Why It's a Winning Play

"Play is the highest form of research."  - Albert Einstein “Play is the work of the child.”  – Maria Montessori In our recently remodeled school media center, we have a space dedicated to active engagement in fun learning activities. Part maker space, part literacy lounge, board games are being incorporated to promote a culture of joyful learning. Whether it's a game of Rummy , Yahtzee , or Scrabble , family game night serves as a communication elixir and solidifies our domestic climate of togetherness. Shouldn't similar opportunities for interaction, challenge, and fun exist somewhere in our schools? Broken families, cultural fragmentation, and poverty are impacting opportunities for children to play. As we unpacked and tagged our new media center games, I was more disappointed than shocked by the number of students who had never played Monopoly , Boggle , or Sorry . One skeptical teacher commented, "Oh great, now we're letting students pl

Self-Directed vs. Self-Determined Learning; What's the Difference?

"We need to move beyond the idea that an education is something that is provided for us, and toward the idea that an education is something that we create for ourselves." - Stephen Downes In this age of abundance of information, shifting classroom pedagogy isn't nearly enough to make learning in school more relevant and authentic for the learner. Self-directed learning ( andragogy ), and self-determined learning ( heutagogy ) are the ideals necessary in making students " future ready " to live and learn in a web-connected world. While original research applied these concepts to mature learners, it has become apparent that even young children have an abundant capacity for recognizing and directing their learning. Anyone who has observed toddlers learning how to walk and talk understand the motivation and skill development that quickly develops during these processes. Considered by some to be on a learning continuum, self-directed learning, and self-determined